Create account

anarchovegan
replied 2000d
Sk8eM dUb
Could you explain what a free-for-all anarchist society is?
Metalbrushes_Tattoo
replied 1999d
It would probably look a lot like “Burning Man” if I were to guess 🤔
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
That's not very helpful.
I haven't been to burning man.
Metalbrushes_Tattoo
replied 1999d
Google and YouTube can be an excellent resource to learn more about places and experiences you haven’t had but are interested in ;)
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
Yes, and you could also tell me what you mean by "free for all anarchist society".
I don't care about burning man.
I'm asking you what You mean.
Metalbrushes_Tattoo
replied 1999d
https://burningman.org/event/preparation/first-timers-guide/
This is a good place to start if you want to see why I thought Burning Man when I read “free for all anarchist society”
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
Found the words "law enforcement" on there. This is not anarchy.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
Isolate them with no food and see what happens next.
Metalbrushes_Tattoo
replied 1999d
They would probably just go find food. Hunt/gather and share as a community because that is the philosophy that Burning Man brings.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
lol I thought it was in the desert. I'm saying introduce actual scarcity so people have to start deciding between altruism and personal survival. You'll get a few "criminals", then...
Metalbrushes_Tattoo
replied 1999d
Obviously if you put people in a situation where they have no food or water they are going to start fighting. Law enforcement or anarchy doesn’t matter. Survival can become savage.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1998d
Not necessarily starvation level famine, just enough scarcity that there are winners and losers in food production which means inequality. You'll have a government in no time.
Simon Van Gelder
replied 1999d
I've heard a shepherd does wonders in such a situation.
Metalbrushes_Tattoo
replied 1999d
I have no clue what your meaning by this. Care to elaborate?
Simon Van Gelder
replied 1999d
People with no resources in the desert are animals, which a shepherd can lead and care for.
Metalbrushes_Tattoo
replied 1999d
“free for all anarchist society” wasn’t a term I used. Sorry I kinda jumped in on your conversation with someone else because when I read that I immediately thought burning man
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
no no no, please jump in! It's a fascinating topic, I'm still thinking through it.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
So... what do you mean by it?
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
Indeed.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 2000d
Watch Princess Mononoke, pretty much that. No different than straight up feudalism. If you amass any wealth there'll be raiding parties of samurai at your door every damn day.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
And why do you think if you amass wealth they'll be raiding parties of samurai every day?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
Why do you think there wouldn't be?
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
It depends on if people defend taxation, the blind obedience to authority.
That is what enables that.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
So what do you think should happen to people who "defend taxation in blind obedience to authority"?
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
That, if they are so open, they talk with me or someone else who advocates for anarchy, a society where none hold the blind belief in authority?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
And how do you propose to achieve that?
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
By talking with them, as I am currently doing with you.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
Perhaps you're right. However, the statement isn't useful in the least because the alternative(feudalism) is much much worse.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
What statement?
What do you mean that feudalism is the only alternative?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
The statement "taxation is theft" is like a child complaining that it's not fair he has to do chores to get an allowance. As the parent I'd say 'don't let the door hit you in the ass!'
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
How is "Taxation is theft" like that?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
The kid wants the benifits of living in the household he was born in without any obligations. You want the benifits of the society you were born into with none of the trade-offs.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
Being born into a society that organizes using theft validates that theft?
Is the taxation repealed when child matures?
Aren't families communistic?
Is everyone a perpetual child?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
It's a limited analogy. You know that demanding perfect solutions is a socialist tactic? Gotta say I'm disappointed. I thought I'd learn from you but it seems you're just an NPC.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
How am I demanding perfect solutions?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
By taking an analogy farther than it was clearly meant to illustrate the point I was making.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
What point were you illustrating?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
Read it again. If you can't understand that I doubt you understand Murray Rothbard either.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
So, you don't want to reiterate fit clarification.
Well, it was nice talking with you.
Have a good day.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
peace
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
Peace.
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
Anarchism becomes feudalism because of the Pareto principle. A small amount of people will own most/all of the land. A monopoly on land ownership is feudalism by definition.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
Why would a small amount of people in anarchy own most/all the land?
Sk8eM dUb
replied 1999d
Haven't convinced me of anything other than that you blindly, dogmatically, definitionally believe to the idea that a tax is necessarily a violent violation of your property rights.
anarchovegan
replied 1999d
I don't expect to convince you of anything in one conversation. I don't understand how you're concluding that I'm dogmatic about taxation. Could you explain that?